ANOTHER MIDFIELD DILEMMA
RECAPS
EXTRA TIME
CHRISTOPHER MCCOLLUM - Monday, February 7, 2011
Clint Dempsey, Stuart Holden, Jonathan Spector, Jermaine Jones, and Michael Bradley. One of these is not like the others. Any guesses who?

If you guessed Stuart Holden's impeccable hair-styling over the no-nonsense frills of the others, you would be correct. If you guessed Jermaine Jones never playing in a meaningful game for the U.S. National Team, you would also be correct. If you guessed Clint Dempsey being the sole soul of the quintet who actively displays his freestyle rapping skills during interviews and for Nike commercials, that would be another correct choice. However, for the purpose of the game, we're going to go with Jonathan Spector being the odd-man out in a midfield lineup.

For almost the entirety of Spector's professional and international career, he has maintained his role in the defense, whether it be on the right or in the middle. However, during a recent two month spell at West Ham, he has gotten more than his fair share of looks in the central midfield, which admittedly came as quite the surprise to most pundits and fans.

His surprise start against Manchester United in the Carling Cup back in November went against the grain where he was an unused sub for five of the past seven games, and didn't play a single minute in the month of October. The selection provided ammunition for an angry reaction from a fan base that perhaps was equaled only by the angry reactions from other fan bases over questionable lineup moves, the US national team not excluded.

West Ham's fan website was rife with mocking "there goes the neighborhood" comments, until 22 minutes in when Spector hit the back of the net with the opening goal of the game. There was excitement, relief, and many comments questioning the validity of their original reactions.

Then, 15 minutes later, Spector struck again, and the excitement and relief quickly turned to calls for Spector to be named president, the greatest West Ham player of all time, and there may have even been a marriage proposal or two in the heat of the moment.

West Ham went on to win that game by a score of 4-0, and Spector quickly became a regular starter in several more games over the next two months. He scored four goals while assisting on two in all competitions during that span, and many questions have been raised over whether or not he should get a midfield look on the national team as well.

If Spector were to be given a shot in the central midfield, the most obvious concern will be his lack of speed, and if he would be able to contain some of the quicker midfielders he would be facing in CONCACAF, or if they will zip around him without much trouble. He has been exposed in the back before, but that liability would be less of a risk in the midfield, where he likely wouldn't be in the scenario where he's the last man back.

If he were paired alongside a quicker partner, such as Michael Bradley, there would be good coverage in the central midfield defensively, as well as having a battery of skilled lockdown players who can distribute the ball and score goals, rather than having one lockdown central midfielder and one who runs the attack.

Of course, this would lead to a slower rate of play, as well as the lack of a true playmaker in the center. This can be solved by shifting formations around, with the first coming to mind as a 3-5-2.

Imagine a triangle of center midfielders, with two holding, lockdown players keeping the middle third clean and organized, distributing long balls and supporting the backline, while a playmaker, such as Jose Torres or Benny Feilhaber for example‘s sake, sits at the pinnacle and runs the game.

Done correctly, the national team's penchant for holes in the midfield leading to early opposition chances and goals should be corrected.

The obvious problems with the Jonathan Spector Scenario is that Bob Bradley prefers to run a 4-4-2 formation, and the national team is enjoying a deep pool of midfield talent without having to move players up from the back line.

With the recent moves of Bradley and Jones to the Premier League, it puts one possible midfield lineup all playing in the toughest league in the world, which is perhaps a dream scenario for Coach Bradley and fans.

Everyone knows the success of Dempsey's Fulham career (currently sitting with ten league goals on the season, he has tied the American record for goals in a single Premier League season), just like everyone knows how invaluable Bolton has considered Stuart Holden to be since his arrival.

Throw in Jones who, despite committing a ridiculous foul that could have easily been called a penalty kick, was named man of the match in his first game with Blackburn. Jones' Bundesliga play and reputation is well known, as is Bradley's rising stature in Europe. Bradley is expected to make an immediate splash at Aston Villa, where he will be united for the first time with the original intimidating bald American, Brad Friedel.

Throw in Ricardo Clark, Maurice Edu, Landon Donovan, Mikkel Diskerud, Torres, Feilhaber, Robbie Rogers, the nearly forgotten Freddy Adu, so on and so forth, and the US is truly swimming in options.

Despite that availability of talent, there really hasn't been a consistently good central midfield tandem since the Claudio Reyna/Ernie Stewart days, which is why the elder Bradley must continue looking at options, until something clicks.

It almost seems like beating a dead horse at this point, but one only needs to look at Spain and Barcelona's tandem of Xavi andAndres Iniesta to be inspired to put together fantasy midfield pairings for the American team, to enhance productivity and quality of play.

While we can't expect to magically find the skill-set of a midfield pair that were on the short list of Balon d'Or voting for 2010, we should be able to find a quality pair of regular center midfielders who can consistently produce quality showings.

Bradley cemented himself into national team lore as a clutch player with his goal against Slovenia in last year's World Cup, but his role cannot be seen as cemented, nor should anyone else's.

Given Spector's surprising midfield play against top flight teams in the world's toughest league, as well as his recognized quality of distribution and touch on the ball, it stands to reason that he should at least be given a shot on the national team level.

Perhaps in an upcoming friendly, or perhaps during the early stages of this summer's Gold Cup; Regardless of when it is, it needs to happen, if only to scratch that option off the list if it proves unworkable.

If it does work, then we'll have the luxury that pretty much only the English national team has: An entire legitimate midfield selection playing in the Premiership. That can't be a bad thing.
Mike
Friday February 18, 2011 7:54 am
Why is Ricardo Clark mentioned on this article??? Do you have alzheimer's???
Phil
Friday February 18, 2011 7:25 am
Sorry I'm coming late to the party, but I too wonder is we'd benefit from employing a 3 man backfield. It's doing wonders for Napoli, who currently sit 2nd in Serie A and have a coach that clearly thinks putting his bet players on the field requires him coming up with a system that accomadtes what he has to work with. Several facts make me think this:

1. we don't have an international-class left back, nor do we have a prospect emerging. While Bocanegra comes closest, he is most at home in a CB role and he is coming to at the end of is Nats days.

2. We have quite a few strong CB and DM players and prospects.

3 + 4. We have a slew of quality midfielders (including Spector and apparantly even Bornstein) and creative central type who could be playmakers (Dempsey, Donovan, Holden Feilhaber) or comfortbale as a withdrawn striker (LD and Deuce)

5. Until CD9 is really back, we only have 1 true international striker (Altidore) with a few young prospects and a few role players/subs (Gomez and Findley)
--Deuce--Jozy--LD--
-----MB--Stuart-----
-----Edu--Jones----
Boca--Gooch--'dolo
------Howard-------

subs: Feilhaber, Bedoya, Goodson, Mixx, Spector, Lichaj, Agudelo, Gomez, Torres
Alex from Bham
Thursday February 10, 2011 2:44 pm
@Jonnie reb 4-3-2-1 I like that also! More help for Jozy. But Yeah 3 in the back would be an absolute scandal. @Timothy Never again do I ever want to see Spector play in the back. He has been continually beaten, embarrassed and made to look a fool back there. When the back line is pushed up he is often to slow to get back. I've see it time and time again from him. Plain and simple, in my opinion at least, he is a liability in the back. And as far as your comment on center backs, Gooch (when he is fit), Goodson, Boca, DeMerit, Gonzalez (even though young), Ream- All fine by me and worth a shot at least.
Timothy
Thursday February 10, 2011 8:57 am
Why would anyone even think about adding spector to the mid....we need defenders now more than ever, especially in the center. We need someone in the center off defend who is comfortable with the ball at their feet.
Jason
Wednesday February 9, 2011 11:07 pm
Forgive my last comment, you did mention the other CM options, no more posting for me after 11:00 PM. Apologies.
Jason
Wednesday February 9, 2011 11:04 pm
Good article, except the formation shift was a bit strange.

4-5-1 is the dominant formation throughout world football right now. The US has a bunch of midfielders and a thin group at forward. 4-5-1 (or some other variation thereof: 4-3-3, 4-3-2-1, 4-2-3-1) seems much more likely than 3-5-2 to me.

And why no love for Maurice Edu? If we are talking CMs/DM's, he should be in there. Torres is still plugging away also. And Feilhaber. And Diskerud. And Bedoya. If we go 4-5-1 all those guys could be option for the CAM role, or even a LCM role in some sort of 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1.
Jonnie reb
Wednesday February 9, 2011 3:50 pm
Only 3 back would scare me. We're not there yet. On the other hand, we could play a 4-3-3/4-3-2-1 with three midfielders (like Holden, Spector, Bradley, or Bradley, Jones, Edu or some combination, and then with one true striker and Lando and Deuce a little withdrawn and coming in frm the wings. Then we would truly be two deep in every midfield position and we would maitain an attacking threat with Dempsey and Landon filling in as attacking forwards.
Alex from Bham
Tuesday February 8, 2011 11:39 am
@Aaron. 4-5-1? Worth a try! I could picture Jozy as a lone striker (although he tends to need help or he loses the ball easily) Lando and Holden as wingers, and a combo between Bradley, Jones, Edu, Feilhaber etc. in the center. One of those guys would play a bit deeper, who depending on the line up. And maybe Dempsey withdrawn a bit behind Jozy....Why not? Bob needs to find some way to get goals up front before the upcoming cups. Now is the time to experiement!
Aaron
Tuesday February 8, 2011 10:08 am
Good read, looking forward to more. I think The USMNT Struggles with 4 defenders. If we are going to changes the shape, I'd suggest a 4-5-1 with Deuce or Landon supporting the striker as the strikers rarely score anyhow.

We have 3-4 keepers that would not scare me if they started, about 8 central(holding) midfielders, a few that can play right wing, but no left backs or strikers making the spot thier own. Jose will start all most every match no matter of form, Charlie was/is our best option but he is not ready.....man Brian McBride should have been cloned 7- years ago so we had a striker that we could count on.
Ed C.
Tuesday February 8, 2011 7:16 am
concur - 3 defenders? wish we had 3 solid defenders!! the midfield is ok, but a handful of decent performances by spector doesn't make him the next midfield maestro. holden is still unproven as well, so let's not get ahead of ourselves here young Christopher!
Page 1 of 2
1 2  Next »
ADD YOUR COMMENTS
Name


Email (will not appear on the site)


Comment


Join the YA Email Alert?

Comments are moderated and will be posted if they are on-topic and free of profanity, abuse and spam. HTML and links are not allowed.

SUBMIT COMMENT

A big question for U.S. fans heading into the World Cup is surely on Jozy Altidore and just what is plaguing the young striker at Sunderland.
RECENT POSTS
USMNT - Mexico ratings
Green must avoid Adu-like hype
Tension with Russia creep in
Decisions await Johannsson
THIS WEEK'S HEADLINES

RANDOM TAGS FROM PAST WEEK...
Alejandro Bedoya, Geoff Cameron, FC Nantes, Tim Howard, Sunderland, Under-20 National Team